Phylogenetic approaches to linguistic and cultural evolution promise to increase our understanding of human prehistory and adaptation. Below we illustrate the application of the phylogenetic comparative approach to testing hypotheses about the evolution. Holden department of anthropology, university college london, gower street, london, uk, wc1e 6bt there has been a rapid increase in the use of phylogenetic methods to study the evolution of languages and culture. Phylogenetic comparative methods take account of the nonindependence of cultures galtons problem, which can cause spurious statistical associations in comparative analyses. The beginning of the new millennium has seen a renaissance of biological metaphors of pattern and process of change in the domain of cultural evolution mace and holden 2005.
Cultural phylogenetics concepts and applications in archaeology. Human phylogenetic history and the paleontological record. A population geneticsbased and phylogenetic approach to. Phylogenetic reconstruction of bantu kinship challenges.
Mar 31, 2021 this chapter focuses on cultural or sociocultural evolution. On 12 may, 2019, about 2 296 2 papers are found, but typing phylogeny or epidemiology and phyloge. Advances in phylogenetic methods offer new possibilities for the analysis of cultural evolution, including estimating the rate of evolution and the. The applications and challenges of cultural phylogenetics. So since there is indeed a considerable lack of sync between hominid. Conventional phylogenetic techniques, while helpful in some cases, do not provide a. The case for quantitative statistical approaches to the empirical evolution of linguistic and cultural features was presented. There has been a rapid increase in the use of phylogenetic methods to study the evolution of languages and culture. Both programs have their roots in 19th century biology and social philosophy, in the work of darwin, spencer, james and others.
May 31, 2005 this volume tackles questions of cultural evolution empirically and quantitatively, using a range of case studies from africa, the pacific, europe, asia and america. While most students of evolutionary biology are intimately familiar with the neodarwinian synthesis of the 1930s and 40s, a more recent evolutionary synthesis has perhaps gone unnoticed. Hodgson sympathizes with the evolutionary hayek, arguing that hayeks methodological individualism involves an ontogenetic approach to social science, while his evolutionary thinking suggests a phylogenetic approach. Therefore, relatedness amongst cultural elements often resides at the conceptual level not captured by traditional phylogenetic methods. Comparative phylogenetic methods and the cultural evolution of medicinal plant use irene teixidortoneu1,2, fiona m. This paper takes a cognitively inspired approach to analyzing material cultural history.
Methodological individualism and cultural evolution. Language trees represent an especially suitable model. Ultimately, the evolutionary conclusions will depend on the phylogeny used in the study. A phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution request pdf. In particular, a purely neutral model of evolution brownian motionis used to model the evolutionary dynamics of a trait thought to be evolving in response to some selective factor harvey and purvis. This issue is much debated, but i focus my attention on a quite original incompatibility argument by geoffrey hodgson.
Evolutionary archaeology in the earlytomid 20th century the social and political implications of early cultural evolutionary thinking, such as eugenics and other atrocities, understandably promoted a reaction, and the social sciences turned towards a thoroughly anti. In order not to argue entirely in the abstract, we. This thesis uses a supertree approach to infer a composite phylogeny of human populations based on published phylogenetic trees based on genetic and linguistic data. These methods have previously been used in numerous studies of linguistic and cultural evolution 20. Independent instances of change include the acquisition or loss of a trait, either by original invention or by copying from another culture. Powerful theoretical tools developed in evolutionary biology are used to test detailed hypotheses about historical patterns and adaptive functions in cultural evolution.
Phylogenetic approach to the evolution of color term systems. Mar 01, 2005 among the many recent studies applying phylogenetic methods to languages and other aspects of cultural variation, two subfields stand out in particular. Citeseerx a phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution. Phylogenetic analysis irit orr subjects of this lecture 1 introducing some of the terminology of phylogenetics. Evolutionary epistemology stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Using a darwinian approach virtually all aspects of human behavior show enormous variation both within and between cultural groups, including material culture. An evolutionary developmental approach to cultural evolution. This procedure allowed the colonization of the spore print with environmental bacteria. As the number of considered species increases, the number of potential phylogenetic resolutions also increases exponentially fig. Following previous phylogenetic comparative studies of cultural traits 7,19,27,28, we employed language trees as a model for population histories. He argues that the latter involves an ontogenetic approach to social science, while his evolutionary thinking suggests a phylogenetic approach. Bayesian phylogenetic analysis supports an agricultural.
Jul 19, 2016 a phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution. Jan 11, 2001 the other program attempts to account for the evolution of ideas, scientific theories, epistemic norms and culture in general by using models and metaphors drawn from evolutionary biology. These techniques map the traits of interest in this case descent and residence onto a phylogenetic tree, which represents the way societies are related to each. Testing for divergent transmission histories among cultural. A modeling approach for adaptive evolution marguerite a. Evolutionary tree of life from the time of charles darwin, it has been a dream for many biologists to reconstruct the evolutionary history of all organisms on earth and express it in the form of a phylogenetic tree haeckel 1866. Pdf a phylogenetic approach to the history of cultural.
This paper takes a cognitively inspired approach to analyzing material cultural. Human evolutionary ecology group, department of anthropology, university college london, uk. Languages fit a tree model of evolution well, at least in their basic vocabulary, challenging the view that blending, or admixture among neighbouring groups, was predominant in cultural history. But this approach alone cannot reveal all the details of language evolution and there are other darwinian approaches that are making great contributions to advance our knowledge of the phenomenon. It begins with a discussion of the darwinianinspired evolutionary approach to history. Download pdf did you struggle to get access to this article. Download the ebook the evolution of cultural diversity. A unifying theme is that the phylogenetic approach is a useful and powerful framework, both for describing the evolutionary history of these traits, and also for testing adaptive hypotheses about. Orsi, and martin wiedmann department of food science, cornell university, ithaca, new york 14853 received 18 february 2010accepted 12 july 2010. Comparative phylogenetic methods and the cultural evolution of medicinal plant use.
Fitch, trends in genetics 2000 textbooks molecular evolution. Phylogenetic trees of gene sequences are a powerful tool for recovering evolutionary relationships among species, and can be used to answer a broad range of evolutionary and ecological questions. Phylogenetics and material cultural evolution current. Modeling the evolution of cultural traits using phylogenetic comparative methods developed for biological pro. Phylogenetic approaches to material cultural evolution. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Virtually all aspects of human behavior show enormous variation both within and between cultural groups, including material culture, social organization and language. Recently there has been a movement in the social sciences to apply theories and methods developed originally in evolutionary biology to understand human. This approach is based on the wellestablished correspondences between population dispersals and the diversification of linguistic lineages. Demonstrates how cultural phylogenetics models the evolution of material culture.
Cultural evolution elizabeth hannon and tim lewens outline 1. Defining culture for most of the twentieth century, evolutionary theory focused on phenotypic variation underpinned by inherited genetic variation. The applications and challenges of cultural phylogenetics in. Virtually all aspects of human behavior show enormous variation both within and between cultural groups, including material culture, social organization and. Phylogenetic methods using cognate codings of basic. On 12 may, 2019, about 2 296 2 papers are found, but typing phylogeny or epidemiology and phylogeny. The phylogenetic approach in cross cultural research. A phylogenetic approach is one of the most notable endeavours to produce insights into the mode and tempo of language evolution. Comparative phylogenetic methods and the cultural evolution.
A phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution sciencedirect. Evolutionary theory has been discussed in american archaeology. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Oct 04, 2012 hodgson sympathizes with the evolutionary hayek and aims his arrows especially at hayeks methodological individualism. Torque creation and force variation along the cutting edges of acheulean handaxes. Testing for divergent transmission histories among. The origins and descent of the southeast asian tradition of warp ikat weaving christopher d. Advances in phylogenetic methods offer new possibilities for the analysis of cultural evolution, including estimating the rate of evolution and the direction of coevolutionary change of traits on the tree. Pdf a conceptual networkbased approach to inferring the. Comparative phylogenetic methods and the cultural evolution of. A comparative phylogenetic approach to austronesian.
Phylogenetic comparative methods were used to test hypotheses about cultural evolution in ethnolinguistic groups from the austronesian language family of the pacific. This is illustrated by the use of phylogenetic methods to analyze artifact distributions e. Evolutionary archaeology in the earlytomid 20th century the social and political implications of early cultural evolutionary thinking, such as eugenics and other atrocities, understandably promoted a reaction, and the social sciences turned towards a thoroughly antibiological stance. The phylogenetic approach for viral infectious disease. Finding the true phylogenetic hypotheses from a large number of alternative trees is a very complex task. A population geneticsbased and phylogenetic approach to understanding the evolution of virulence in the genus listeria henk c. Phylogenetic reconstruction of bantu kinship challenges main. In recent decades, phylogenetic methods originated in evolutionary biology have been put forward as fruitful strategies to trace and reconstruct the origin, development, distribution, and interrelatedness of archaeological artifacts and traditions.
Modern phylogenetic comparative methods and their application. It then outlines modern evolutionary phylogenetic methods borrowed from biology but now used extensively in the social sciences and humanities. Buckley independent researcher, beijing, peoples republic of china abstract the warp ikat method of making decorated textiles is one of the most geographically widespread in southeast. Taxonomy is the science of classification of organisms. Professor geoffrey hodgson is an economist with a longtime interest in evolutionary thinking, his contributions ranging from economics and evolution 1993 to economics in the shadow of darwin and marx. Pdf studies of cultural adaptation and evolution are important for advancing our. I examine future areas of cultural phylogenetic research in the evolutionary social sciences and argue that the kinds of studies introduced in this article hold the potential for fruitful collaborations between cultural phylogeneticists and cross cultural researchers. Spatially mediated cultural transmission and the distribution of horse blanket styles among postcontact and reservationperiod tribes of western north america. Nov 29, 2016 to evaluate the basic evolutionary claims of the wcs theory, we use a bayesian phylogenetic method for the study of trait evolution, implemented with the bayestraits software package. The phylogenetic approach in cross cultural research show all authors. They are also beginning to permeate the medical sciences.
Dec 09, 2014 phylogenetic comparative methods, adapted from evolutionary biology, offer an alternative way of reconstructing the evolutionary history of cultural traits such as kinship structures. A conceptual networkbased approach to inferring the cultural. An evolutionary framework for cultural change arxiv. Phylogenetic approaches to cultural evolution have often been criticized because a single tree cannot capture relationships that involved admixture among populations, but using a range of trees enables more than one evolutionary pathway to be represented for such cultures, in a comparable way to using a network model. A phylogenetic approach ruth mace in pdf or epub format and read it directly on your mobile phone, computer or any device. An evolutionary developmental approach to cultural evolution 155 ation in cultural style and complexity e. Human population history revealed by a supertree approach. Pdf phylogenetics and material cultural evolution researchgate. Hawkins1 1university of reading, school of biological sciences, harborne building, whiteknights campus, reading, berkshire, uk rg6 6aj 2universitetet i oslo, naturhistorisk museum, sars gate 1 oslo, no 0562. Comparative phylogenetic analyses uncover the ancient. Ontogenetic and phylogenetic approaches to social order. These chapters are followed by sections on each of the four dominant approaches.
We propose the adoption of the term phylomemetics for phylogenetic analysis of reproducing nongenetic elements. A comparative phylogenetic approach to austronesian cultural evolution. A comparative phylogenetic approach to austronesian cultural. Phylogenetic approach to the evolution of color term. This thesis uses a supertree approach to infer a composite phylogeny of human populations based on published phylogenetic trees based on. For biological structures, similarity and congruence tests are used to differentiate parallelism, convergence and homology 43, 4850. May 31, 2011 phylogenetic methods have also been used for some time to analyse the evolution of languages and the development of physical cultural artefacts.
Recent applications of biological phylogenetic methodology to infer historical patterns of material culture are often explicitly justified on the grounds that essentially similar processes underlie evolution in both biological and material cultural realms. A phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution ruth mace and clare j. In culture, units of transmission are not just measurable attributes, but communicable concepts. Such research requires a robust phylogenetic hypothesis of human populations as a framework. The book focuses on understanding the evolutionary origin of humans and their biological and cultural traits.
Investigating cultural evolution using phylogenetic analysis. These methods have previously been used in numerous studies of linguistic and cultural evolution 2023. The study of evolution at the molecular level has given the subject of evolutionary biology a new significance. A conceptual networkbased approach to inferring the. King department of ecology and evolutionary biology, university of tennessee, knoxville, tennessee 379961610 submitted november 26, 2003. These studies can help to answer a range of anthropological questions. Request pdf a phylogenetic approach to cultural evolution there has been a rapid increase in the use of phylogenetic methods to study the evolution of languages and culture. Stephen lycett publications stephen lycett sjlycett. Investigating processes of cultural evolution on the north coast of new guinea with multivariate and cladistic analyses. Cultural evolution and archaeology lu research portal. The similarity test for structures is based on observations of. In the last decade, the phylogenetic approach is recurrent in molecular evolutionary analysis.
216 996 1223 685 1601 327 1430 893 1011 443 64 418 1243 812 669 1278 1079 567 477 496 1667 1283 324 1228